Based on my KSCCN article Structural Transformation in the Global South: Innovation and Enterprise as the New Engines of Development (Volume II) (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24126744).
From transfers to engines
Yesterday's piece argued that the classical development mechanisms, aid as a net transfer, openness without connectivity and the labour ladder, are running out. This companion asks the constructive question: if those mechanisms are exhausted, what actually moves an economy now? My answer is four engines: digital public infrastructure, sovereign computing capacity, domestically anchored enterprise finance, and enterprises that turn institutional voids into design spaces.
The urgency is real. Aid from DAC members fell 23.1 per cent in real terms in 2025, the largest drop on record, and between 2022 and 2025 low- and middle-income countries paid USD 436 billion more in debt service than they received in new financing. The World Bank counts 108 middle-income countries, many facing the middle-income trap once the returns to basic infrastructure and imported technology fade.
1. Investment without innovation hits a ceiling
Capital accumulation without domestic capability yields diminishing returns. Kazakhstan's metallurgical sector is a clear illustration: investment-led expansion, but R&D and patenting stayed disconnected from production growth, and national R&D spending was 0.16 per cent of GDP in 2024 against a world average of 2.60 per cent. The threshold that matters is the move from importing technology, to adapting it, to creating it.
2. Digital public infrastructure is the new substrate
If roads and ports defined the industrial era, open digital rails define this one: identity, instant payments and data exchange, built as public goods.
- India's UPI processed a record 21.6 billion transactions in December 2025 and about 228 billion over the year, worth nearly USD 3.4 trillion. With a zero merchant discount rate, it removed the fees that kept micro-merchants out of digital payments. One study of 200 villages found business registrations up by as much as 27 per cent where UPI integration was highest.
- Brazil's Pix, launched by the central bank in November 2020 with mandatory participation for large institutions, handled 79.6 billion transactions in 2025. About 86 per cent of Brazilians over 14 used it, and it cost merchants about 0.33 per cent per transaction against 2.34 per cent for credit cards (Q4 2022). Person-to-business payments reached 43 per cent of Pix traffic.
| Year | Pix transactions | Value (USD) |
| 2021 | 9.4 billion | 0.96 trillion |
| 2023 | 41.7 billion | 3.4 trillion |
| 2025 | 79.6 billion | 6.3 trillion |
Source: Banco Central do Brasil payment statistics.
The honest caveat matters as much as the headline. India's ONDC, an open commerce network built on the Beckn protocol, reached about 17.9 million transactions a month by August 2025, but most were mobility rides and logistics; retail orders fell from 6.1 million to 3.8 million in a year. Open protocols lower barriers; they do not guarantee adoption. Governance, consumer protection and state capacity do the rest.
3. Compute is the new binding constraint
In the classical model the binding constraint was foreign exchange. Now it is compute: GPU clusters, memory and the power to run them, all rationed by capital intensity, supply limits and export controls. Countries without domestic capacity risk becoming compute deserts, passive consumers of foreign-hosted systems. By mid-2025 nearly 70 countries had national AI strategies. Four archetypes are visible:
- Capital-abundant, compute-intensive: Gulf states using sovereign wealth to enter the frontier tier.
- Scale and DPI-integrated: India's AI mission made more than 38,000 GPUs available by October 2025 at about ₹65 per GPU-hour, treating compute as a public good for startups.
- Renewable power arbitrage: Brazil, with 88 per cent renewable electricity, and Paraguay's hydropower surplus position themselves as clean compute hubs, while grid limits elsewhere show power as the ultimate gate.
- Ecosystem partnerships: Africa holds about 18 per cent of the world's population but less than 1 per cent of data-centre capacity; operator partnerships, as in Viet Nam and Thailand, are the realistic route.
4. Venture capital as development finance
With aid shrinking, domestic risk capital matters more. Of USD 425 billion invested globally in 2025, the United States took 64 per cent. Yet emerging ecosystems recalibrated: MENA reached USD 7.5 billion, Southeast Asia USD 5.2 billion, Latin America USD 4.1 billion and Africa USD 4.1 billion (provider definitions differ). In Africa, venture debt hit a record USD 1.64 billion, 41 per cent of the total, suited to asset-heavy cleantech and energy firms; cleantech equity rose 186 per cent. African investors were the largest single group of active participants in 2024. The weak spot is early-stage capital: Southeast Asian seed funding fell 57 per cent.
5. Institutional voids as design spaces
Pay-as-you-go asset finance shows how enterprise can build trust where banks are absent. In Sub-Saharan Africa, 42 per cent of adults, some 300 million people, had no account in 2024. M-KOPA finances smartphones, solar systems and e-motorbikes through small daily repayments, with remote locking replacing collateral; it has served more than 7 million customers and disbursed over USD 2 billion in credit. The repayment trail itself becomes a credit history, opening further loans for health, education and business.
What follows for policy
- Treat DPI as a macroeconomic prerequisite: low-fee payment rails and open commerce protocols that collapse transaction costs and contest platform monopolies.
- Treat compute as critical infrastructure: data centres, data residency and AI talent deserve the priority once given to grids and transport, using partnerships where public capital is short.
- Build domestic risk capital: clear regulation, startup frameworks and funds of funds to fill the seed gap, especially in climate tech, logistics and applied AI.
- Design for voids, not transplants: mobile-first enterprise and verification tools can create creditworthiness faster than imported institutional templates.
For diplomacy and trade policy, the implication is practical. Negotiating access to payment interoperability, compute partnerships and co-investment vehicles is now as consequential as negotiating tariff lines. The economies that escape the middle-income trap will be those that stop being passive consumers of imported technology and capital and become architects of their own rails, compute and enterprise.
Read the full paper
KSCCN