The Math I Use to Decide If a SaaS Tool Is Actually Worth It

The Math I Use to Decide If a SaaS Tool Is Actually Worth It

●2 ●4
calendar_today • schedule2 min read

Every team building software ends up with the same recurring question: is this $15/seat tool actually paying for itself, or are we just used to having it around? Most of us answer that with a shrug and a Slack poll. I run SaaS Switcher, a site that tracks SaaS pricing and alternatives, and after reading enough vendor pricing pages I got tired of the shrug, so I put together a small ROI model and turned it into a free calculator.

Here's the formula behind it, in case you want to run it yourself or steal it for an internal tool:

```
monthly_cost = seats cost_per_seat
hours_saved_mo = seats
hours_saved_per_user_per_week 4.33
monthly_value = (hours_saved_mo
hourly_rate) + extra_revenue_per_month
monthly_net = monthly_value - monthly_cost

roi_percent = (monthly_net 12) / (monthly_cost 12) * 100
return_multiple = monthly_value / monthly_cost
```

4.33 is just weeks per month (52 / 12), which is the only slightly clever part. Everything else is arithmetic a spreadsheet could do, which is sort of the point: an ROI number is only as good as the two inputs nobody wants to estimate honestly, hours saved per user and the fully loaded hourly rate.

Worked example: 10 seats, $15/seat/month, 2 hours saved per user per week, $40/hour fully loaded rate, no extra revenue attributed.

  • Monthly cost: $150
  • Hours saved per month: 10 × 2 × 4.33 ≈ 86.6 hours
  • Monthly value: 86.6 × $40 = $3,464
  • Monthly net: $3,314
  • ROI: 2,209% (a 23.1x return)

That last number is why "is this tool worth it" conversations go badly without a formula. $150/month feels small enough to not scrutinize, and 2 hours/week/user feels small enough to round down to zero. Multiply them across a whole team and the answer usually isn't close either way, it's obviously yes or obviously no, and the model gets you there faster than a debate does.

Where this breaks: it's a directional model, not an audit. Hours saved and hourly rate are your own estimates, and if you fudge them the output just launders your bias into a percentage. The honest way to use it is to lowball hours saved and check whether the ROI still holds, not to hunt for the number that justifies a decision you already made.

I put this calculator together so nobody has to keep re-deriving it in a spreadsheet every renewal cycle: SaaS ROI Calculator. Seats, cost per seat, hours saved per week, hourly rate, optional revenue impact, monthly or yearly billing. Nothing goes to a server, your inputs stay in your browser's local storage, no account needed.

Curious how people here would model this differently, especially for tools where the "value" isn't hours saved but something fuzzier: fewer production incidents, faster onboarding, better retention. What would you add to the formula?

2 Comments

1 vote
0 votes
🔥 Join developers growing publicly
Share your knowledge, build in public, and grow your developer presence with a global community.

More Posts

Free SEO Tools Every Small Business Should Use (2026) | FloxoLab

floxolab - Oct 20

I’m a Senior Dev and I’ve Forgotten How to Think Without a Prompt

Karol Modelski - Mar 19

TypeScript Complexity Has Finally Reached the Point of Total Absurdity

Karol Modelski - Apr 23

Make for Small Business: What It Is, What It Costs, and When to Use It

floxolab - Oct 23

Cisco's Amy Chang: A Model's "Passport" Doesn't Tell You Where It Actually Came From

Tom Smithverified - Aug 27
chevron_left
144 Points • 6 Badges
1Posts
0Comments
2Connections
SaaSSwitcher compares business software alternatives and pricing. Every plan price and limit is read... Show more

Commenters (This Week)

3 comments
1 comment

Contribute meaningful comments to climb the leaderboard and earn badges!