Code Quality for AI Systems: Beyond Coverage to Production Reality

Code Quality for AI Systems: Beyond Coverage to Production Reality

●10 ●23
calendar_today • schedule2 min read

Beyond Coverage: Testing an AI Feature Without a Paid Model
This article is about testing, and draws on how I test my current products. What it describes are practices, not measured results.
What coverage tells you, and what it does not
Test coverage tells you which lines of code ran during the tests. It does not tell you whether the tests checked anything that matters, and for a feature that calls a language model it says even less: the code around the model can be fully covered while the behaviour that matters, what the model does with a strange input, is not tested at all. I have no figures on how often this happens. It is a reasoning point, and it matches what I have seen in my own code.
How I test an LLM feature
These are practices, not results.

1. Put the model behind a small interface. The application calls an interface, and the real provider is one implementation. In tests another implementation returns scripted answers.
2. Script the model per scenario. A scenario says: when the user sends this, the safety judge returns this verdict, the reply is this text. Then the test checks what the application did: what was shown, what was saved, what was refused, what reached the log.
3. Use a real temporary database. Mocking the storage hides the bugs that live in it.
4. Break the protection on purpose. After a test passes, remove the protection it is meant to test and confirm that the test now fails. A test that cannot fail is not testing anything.
5. Test the whole program. In my Go projects the real binary is built with a test-only build tag that points it at a stand-in server. The shipped program has no such option.
6. Keep paid runs for the end. A small set of live checks with real models still has to be run by hand, but it is a final check, not the way the code is developed.

None of this proves the feature is safe. It makes the failures you thought of repeatable, and it makes the ones you find later cheap to add.
What Socratic Analyzer does
The library Socratic Analyzer, from my earlier prototype, is a set of analysis tools for project workflows: cost and risk calculation for workflow paths, a path finder, validators for dependencies and syntax, a test executor, a project-maturity calculator, and token-usage tracking. It is useful as a set of building blocks. It does not assess whether an AI agent's decisions are good, and its own tests are mostly import checks, so I would not hold it up as an example of testing.
The checklist, if you want one

• Does every protection have a test that fails without it?
• Can the feature be tested with no paid model?
• Does a failed or empty model answer have a defined, tested result for the user?
• Is it tested that user text does not reach logs?
• Are the live checks written down and repeatable?

If you are working on an LLM feature and want an outside review against a list like this, that is one of the services I offer. See the Services page.

Want more #ai & #codequality deep dives?

Join 5,951+ developers sharing real benchmarks, code breakdowns, and projects. Free forever.

Part 9 of 11 in Socrates-AI

More Posts

The Sovereign Vault — A Comprehensive Guide to Protocol-Driven AI

Ken W. Algerverified - Jun 4

How AI Is Changing Web Development, and What Developers Still Need to Understand

Daniel Decker - Nov 10

Minimum Weight: Code Coverage Gates in Kotlin Multiplatform with Kover

kmp-bits - Sep 23

AI Reliability Gap: Why Large Language Models are not for Safety-Critical Systems

praneeth - Mar 31

Dozens of email accounts: learning AI coding tools as a student

rahuldk1105 - Oct 27
chevron_left
1.3k Points • 33 Badges
11Posts
2Comments
5Connections
Building Socrates: Production AI Multi-Agent Platform (37+ modules). Constitutional governance, RAG ... Show more

Related Jobs

View all jobs →

Commenters (This Week)

5 comments

Contribute meaningful comments to climb the leaderboard and earn badges!