Nice writeup the ownership-based auth fix for the IDOR stood out to me since that kind of hole slips into a lot of CRUD work. What if more teams enforced those rules at the form request layer by default instead of patching after a breach?
That's a fantastic point, Andrew. I couldn't agree more.
Treating authorization in the Form Request as the default practice is a game-changer. It shifts security from an afterthought to a "secure by design" approach.
It's a perfect example of the Single Responsibility Principle: the Form Request handles authorization (ideally calling a Policy), letting the controller focus purely on business logic. This makes the code cleaner, more centralized, and prevents entire classes of vulnerabilities.
Thanks for the great insight!
Impressive work! I really like how you’ve gone beyond basic CRUD and focused on real architectural principles performance optimization, security hardening, and testability.
If I may suggest one more thing to highlight, it’d be the “why it matters” aspect how this architecture translates to better scalability or user experience.
@[Spyros]Thanks for the feedback, Spyros! Excellent point about 'why this matters'.
The architecture I implemented directly impacts Scalability and UX:
Better UX: Refactoring N+1 to a bulk request is the main UX benefit, as it drastically reduces latency in loading lists, ensuring a smooth navigation experience. Furthermore, error handling with 503 Service Unavailable gives the user clear and honest feedback about the unavailability of an external service.
Better Scalability: Clean Architecture and DIP (Dependency Inversion) ensure that domain logic is isolated. This means we can evolve the application, add features, or change the database/framework (easy maintenance and safe expansion) without the dreaded "breaking everything," which is crucial to supporting future growth.
This is an excellent example of applying Clean Architecture and SOLID principles in a real-world Laravel project. The way you handled the N+1 issue and IDOR vulnerability shows solid engineering discipline. I especially like the use of interfaces for decoupling and testability—it keeps the core logic clean and future-proof.
Definitely bookmarking the repo for reference. Great work, Fernando!