In-Place vs Extra Space Algorithms : What’s the Difference?

In-Place vs Extra Space Algorithms : What’s the Difference?

BackerLeader posted 1 min read

When we write algorithms, one of the key things to think about is how much memory our solution needs. You might have heard terms like “in-place” and “extra space” — but what do they really mean?

Let’s break it down simply

In-Place Algorithms

An in-place algorithm changes the input data structure directly without using significant extra memory.

  • You can think of it as modifying things where they already are.
  • Typically, it uses only a few extra variables → O(1) space complexity.

Example (conceptual pseudo code):

for i from 0 to n-1:
    if arr[i] == 0:
        move non-zero elements forward within same array

Here, we aren’t creating any new array, just rearranging existing elements.

Real-world analogy:
Imagine rearranging books on a shelf without taking them off, just swapping positions. That’s in-place.


Extra Space Algorithms

An extra space algorithm creates a new data structure (like another array, list, or hash map) to store results.
This usually means O(n) or more space, depending on how much new memory we allocate.

Example (conceptual pseudo code):

create newArr
for each element in arr:
    if element != 0:
        append to newArr
add remaining zeros at the end

Here, we’re using a new array to store data. Easier to write and sometimes clearer, but consumes more memory.


Which One Should You Use?

It depends!

  • If memory is tight (like in embedded systems or large-scale data), in-place is better.
  • If clarity or simplicity matters more and you can afford extra memory, extra space is fine.

There’s often a trade-off between space and code readability, and understanding this balance helps you write efficient code at scale.


In my Medium article, I’ve explained this concept using a real coding problem, “Move all zeros to the end of an array”, step by step with visuals and dry run. Read it here on Medium

If you read this far, tweet to the author to show them you care. Tweet a Thanks

Nice breakdown of the difference between in-place and extra space algorithms — the book shelf analogy really makes it click. It’s interesting how readability and memory trade off like that. In what ways do you think modern hardware has shifted the importance of this balance?

More Posts

Why Space & Time Complexity Matters in Your Code ?

rahul mishra - Oct 2

Understanding loop detection is like understanding how to find your way out of a maze.

rahul mishra - Sep 30

Mistakes I made in my Software Engineering career

rumaisanaveed - Jan 23

Learn programming languages faster

Hiruthic Sha - Aug 12

LinkedIn vs. dev.to: What's better for Developers ?

ravixalgorithm - Jan 7
chevron_left