Attributeerror: 'list' object attribute 'append' is read-only

posted 4 min read

This article concerns what "'list' object attribute 'append' is read-only" is and how to fix it. This confusing error message usually appears when you're trying to change a list in your code but find that it's not letting you do it. This error occurs when you try to set the append attribute on a list object. In this blog, we will learn how to correctly use this append function on a list. By the end of our journey, you'll be equipped with the knowledge and solutions needed to conquer the challenge posed by this particular error, giving you greater control over your list of objects and improving your programming skills. So, let's dive in.

Here is an example of how this error occurs.

my_list = ['one', 'two', '3']

# Trying to assign a value to the 'append' attribute, which is read-only
my_list.append = 'four'  

print(my_list) # This will result in the error

Error

This error occurred because we were trying to assign a value to the append attribute of a list, and in Python, the append method of a list is a built-in method, not an attribute that can be reassigned. We were essentially trying to overwrite the append method with the string 'four', which is not allowed.

To append an element to the end of a list, use the append method. To add 'four' to your my_list, you should use the append method like this:

my_list = ['one', 'two', '3']

my_list.append('four')

print(my_list)

So, the correct way is to call the list.append() to add an item to a list.
Correct Way

Note: In Python, you are only allowed to use built-in methods and functions to manipulate data structures like lists. Attempting to reassign or modify built-in methods, such as `append` for lists, is not allowed and will result in errors like the one you encountered.

Other Common Causes

Mistakenly assigning a value to list.append

Another common cause of this error includes 'mistakenly assigning a value to list.append' by assuming it as a variable or whatever.

my_list = [1, 2, 3]

my_list.append = 4  # Error: Trying to assign a value to list.append

In this example, you're trying to assign a value (4) to my_list.append, which is incorrect. The append method of a list is not an attribute that can be assigned a new value. Instead, you should use the method to add elements to the list:

my_list.append(4)  # Correct way to use append method

Having a variable or another object named append in the same scope

Another common cause can be, having a variable with the name append in the same scope.
Here is an example:

append = 42  # Some variable named 'append' in the same scope

my_list = [1, 2, 3]

my_list.append(4)  # Error: Using the variable 'append' instead of the method

In this example, you have a variable named append in the same scope as your list. If you try to use my_list.append(4), Python will interpret it as if you are trying to modify the attribute append of my_list, which is read-only.
To avoid this, use a different variable name or ensure that there's no conflicting name in the scope:

another_variable = 42

my_list.append(4)  # Correct way to use append method without conflicts

Adding Elements to a Python List in a Loop

Now, using the same append function you can add elements to a python list in a loop.

my_list = []  # Initialized an empty list
num_of_elements = 10 #You can replace this with  number of elements you want to add

for i in range(num_of_elements):  
    my_list.append(i)

print(my_list)

There is another similar error that occurs when you try to re-assign or modify a similar built-in function like append() i.e. extend() function.

AttributeError: 'list' object attribute 'extend' is read-only

extend() is another Python built-in function that is used to modify lists by adding elements, but there is a slight difference between the behavior of both functions.

append() vs extend() Function

The key difference between append() and extend() is that append() adds a single element to the end of the list, while extend() adds multiple elements from an iterable to the end of the list. The choice between the two methods depends on whether you want to add individual elements or concatenate lists.

Coding Example:

my_list = [1, 2, 3]
another_list = [4, 5, 6]

my_list.extend = another_list  //Error: 'list' object attribute 'extend' is read-only

print(my_list)  

Output

Extend Error

Correct Syntax

my_list = [1, 2, 3]
another_list = [4, 5, 6]

my_list.extend(another_list)

print(my_list) 

Correct One

Using an iterable as a starting point, the list.extend() method adds items to the list.

Note: Don't try to put the outcome of calling the method in a variable because it returns None.

Conclusion

The Python error message "AttributeError: 'list' object attribute is read-only" occurs when you attempt to access or modify a built-in method of a list using the dot notation as if it were an attribute. To clarify and resolve this error, you should call the method using parentheses () instead of attempting to set it as an attribute. In Python, methods are functions associated with objects, and they are called by including the parentheses after the method name.

References

If you read this far, tweet to the author to show them you care. Tweet a Thanks

More Posts

Dict' object has no attribute 'append' python

Muhammad Sameer Khan - Nov 23, 2023

Fixed Attributeerror: module tensorflow has no attribute configproto

Phantom - Aug 26, 2023

Numpy.ndarray' object is not callable Error: Fixed

Muhammad Sameer Khan - Nov 15, 2023

TypeError: 'int' object is not iterable in Python

Ferdy - Oct 26, 2023

How to read a file and search specific word locations in Python

Brando - Nov 8, 2023
chevron_left